Welcome to ChildWild

I’m Sierra. I live in the Boston area with my family.

Contact | About | Subscribe

Rio’s take on the marshmallow test

by Sierra on September 24, 2009 · View Comments

in humor

All this talk about the Marshmallow Test made me curious how my own kid would react. I’m too lazy to actually turn my kid into a lab rat, so I just put the question to her hypothetically after dinner one day.

Me: What would you do if I took you into a room with only a table, a chair and a marshmallow on a plate on the table, and told you that I was going to do some things and that if you waited to eat the marshmallow until I came back, you could have two?

Rio: I would follow you, because I would not like to be left alone in the dark.

Me: Oh. What if there was a light?

Rio: Fire is not enough light.

Me: Fire?

Rio: And then you would give me a whole bag of marshmallows. And a bag of chocolate.

Me: I would what?

Rio: If you have marshmallows, you have to have fire and chocolate and cracker sandwiches. Did you know that is a rule?

Me, following along very slowly: S’mores. oh, yes.

Rio: Yes? You are really going to do this for me? Even though I love sweet treats and you don’t like to buy sweet treats and I am always asking for sweet treats and you are always saying no you are really going to buy me a whole bag of marshmallows and a whole bag of chocolate? In real life? Yay!

Me: um…

(For a less frivolous take on the test, check out this New Yorker article. I’m pretty sure I’m a classic example of a “low-delay” personality: bright, flaky, ADHD, creative, poor impulse control. They’ll probably have to stamp that last one on my gravestone.)

What about you? Would you have eaten the marshmallow?

[ETA: New research analysis from the nice people who brought us Nurtureshock suggests that the Marshmallow Test is so much fluff]

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Related posts:

  1. More cleverness from Rio
  2. Playing With Fire
  3. and in the realm of Rio logic…
  4. Rio’s 2nd Birthday
  5. This Will Help

  • I probably could have delayed, but wouldn't have for a marshmallow or other sweet food item, that's for sure. I might not have even eaten the first item. (Pizza would have been another matter though!)

    (I'm very creative, and have ADHD, so I'm not sure what that says...)
  • I have ADHD, too. Interestingly, this article I just read suggests that while the Marshmallow test is useless as a predictor of intelligence, it is useful in pegging ADHD in preschoolers. Not surprised, me.
  • S.C. Faulkner
    This would be a good example of the legendary, "Epic Fail."
  • Ellen
    PWNED!

    Me, I'd have waited, but mostly because un-roasted marshmallows aren't that interesting.
  • Rio: 1
    Sierra: 0
  • Amy
    Now, then, same thing. I would've eaten the marshmallow, gotten up and left.
  • When I was a kid, I totally wouldn't have eaten the marshmallow, because I would've thought that this is what the adults wanted me to do, delay the gratification. I was *very* fond of pleasing authority figures then.

    I probably would've acted the same, for the same reason, up until fairly recently, the last year perhaps. Now, I don't know.
  • Gena
    I watched a video someone made of this experiment - adorable!
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWW1vpz1ybo
  • Sarah T
    Ha! Did you give her s'mores? Did you make her wait for them? ;-)

    I'm pretty sure I would've waited: "long-term versus short-term optimization" is a catchphrase in my family! (True story.)
  • Minerva
    *grins* Awesome! Got me craving campfires, though.
  • Rosa
    Ha! I love that kid.

    It's hard to tell how I'd've done, but I think I'd've succeeded. I really love delayed gratification if I'm pretty sure that I'll get it in the end. In fact, I regularly do this to myself: delay starting a meal I'm really anticipating, or wait to open a letter with what I'm pretty sure is good news, etc. I don't enjoy it if the outcome is less certain, but with the promise of twice as much marshmallow? I think I could have waited a while.
  • Rosa
    PS: So, when are y'all having s'mores?
  • I told her "someday" but there's no reason it should not be tomorrow.
  • Rowan
    Bwa-ha-ha! That's hilarious!
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: