Welcome to ChildWild

I’m Sierra. I live in the Boston area with my family.

Contact | About | Subscribe

Boycott the Marriott!

by Sierra on August 14, 2009 · View Comments

in news

Apparently this is the week to boycott big businesses. First there was the Whole Foods boycott for health care reform.

And now this lovely story about the Marriott blaming a mom for being raped in front of her little kids in one of their parking garages. The Marriott is arguing in court that this woman “failed to exercise due care for her own safety and the safety of her children and proper use of her senses and facilities.” What did she do that they consider negligent? She walked into a Marriott parking garage and attempted to buckle her kids into their car seats when a man placed a gun at her back, raped her at gunpoint, then moved on to threaten her children.

Take home message: The Marriott believes that no woman or child is safe in their hotels, and that anyone in their right mind would avoid them. I have to say I’m inclined to agree. They certainly won’t be seeing any more dollars from me.

I’m a rape survivor. A few years after I was raped, I had the pleasure of being run over in a crosswalk by a reckless driver. As a part-time grad student, I had no health insurance, so I was left with little choice but to sue for damages to pay my $15,000 in medical bills.

You know what is almost as much fun as being raped? Having an insurance company lawyer bring up your rape at all in an unrelated case, suggest that the rape was probably your fault, that as the kind of woman who gets raped the car accident was also your fault, and you probably threw yourself in front of that car because of your post-traumatic stress disorder. Oh, and you shouldn’t have your medical bills paid, because you failed to properly “mitigate your damages” by not having health insurance in the first place.

Which is to say, I have a small, painful inkling of what it must be like to be the woman at the center of this maelstrom, and it is no fun at all. I feel not just politically outraged but personally insulted at the Marriott’s position.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Related posts:

  1. Cost of medical care
  2. Meeting Dr. Patriarchy
  3. Illegal immigration costs some parents custody
  4. Please do not shout at my bicycle
  5. contraception

  • BigBaldRon
    So, it's Marriotts fault that somebody chose to commit a crime on their property?
  • Marriott's lawyers came up with a pretty thin defense of their client. They probably knew it, but had no other defense. If other guests had warned them about the assailant, they really had no defense.
    I once read about a case, prosecuted successfully, where a woman was raped, in her hotel room. She had demanded that the hotel give her a room on at least the second floor when she made reservations, because she usually traveled alone and tried to be careful, rather than the 1st floor rooms that had doors with rooms that opened to the outside of the building. They claimed they had not gotten her request when she arrived and that the only rooms left were 1st floor rooms, where she was later raped.
    It's not whether the rape happens. It's whether the hotel has taken reasonable precautions.
    Marriott should have settled and apologized. I thought we left blaming the victim back in the 70s.
  • Rich Wilson
    Whether or not the case has merit, I don't think attacking the victim has any place in this case. The Marriott should be basing their defense on whether or not they lived up to their duty to provide an appropriate level of safety in the garage. The fact that she got raped isn't proof that the garage wasn't 'sufficiently' safe. The Marriott can't be required to make anything 100% safe- that doesn't exist. But to say that she should not have gone into the parking garage is ludicrous. What the heck is it for if you can't go there? And if it's only safe for men, isn't that inviting a sexual discrimination suit?

    Did they make it 'reasonably' safe or not? Period.
  • Hobart
    I'm not sure blaming the Marriott for this is right either. Certainly the Marriott didn't encourage the rape to occur. Yes, they should take care to ensure a safe environment for folks, but at what extent? It certainly is known that parking garages, in general, aren't very safe... usually quiet and dark. The take home message for me is that Marriott recognizes that this type of thing can happen anywhere and that individuals need to be aware of that as well. Individuals should protect themselves...not expect that someone else is going to go above and beyond to protect them. It would be nice if they did, but it isn't a reality in our society. Consider if someone got raped in your back yard. Is it your fault because you didn't anticipate it and have security watching over the yard?
  • @ Hobart: Well, people don't pay me to maintain a security detail in my backyard. This woman was paying the Marriott, as their guest, and they do maintain security on behalf of their guests. I believe her suit is based on the fact that their hotel security failed to respond to complaints about her assailant from other guests, and they had not properly trained their staff or placed appropriate security cameras in the parking garage.

    That said, I don't have any real opinion about what the Marriott did or didn't do to prevent this rape. Maybe her complaint is accurate and maybe it isn't. It's pretty clear to me that the fault for the rape lies with the rapist. I'm just appalled that the hotel would suggest the woman was at fault for simply being in their garage. The underlying message is that any responsible woman would know its not safe for her to go anywhere without a man, and I don't buy that.
  • Thanks for posting about this. This story is outrageous. I took action at MomsRising.org: http://bit.ly/16Pj4h
  • I'm so sorry for what you experienced. Please take heart that even those who haven't personally "been there, done that" are equally outraged.

    I am a mother with three young children. It could have been me. My satirical post sums it up but it's needless to say my vagina and I will never go to a Marriott again - how's that for "exercising due care" Marriott?

    Angela <
  • Sue
    Wow. How do some people sleep at night?
  • ...oh, holy gods.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: